Around 300 BCE, in the new city of Alexandria on the coast of Egypt, a Greek king set out to do something no ruler had ever attempted. He wanted to collect every book in the world. Not most of them, not the best of them: every one, in every language, on every subject, gathered under one roof. The result was the Great Library of Alexandria, the most famous library in history. And the story of how it was lost is not quite the one most people have heard.
A King Who Collected Knowledge
Alexandria had been founded by Alexander the Great. When he died, one of his generals, Ptolemy, took control of Egypt and founded a dynasty of Greek-speaking kings. Ptolemy I and his son Ptolemy II wanted their capital to be the cultural center of the world. They built a great research institute called the Mouseion, the “shrine of the Muses,” where scholars could live, study and teach, paid by the king. Next to it was the Library.
The Ptolemies went to remarkable lengths to fill it. Agents were sent across the Mediterranean to buy books. According to one ancient story, every ship that entered the harbor of Alexandria was searched, and any books found on board were taken to the Library to be copied. The Library kept the originals. The owners were given the copies.
Another story says Ptolemy III asked Athens to lend him the official, master copies of the great plays of Aeschylus, Sophocles and Euripides, so they could be copied. The Athenians demanded an enormous deposit of fifteen talents of silver to make sure they came back. Ptolemy paid it, had beautiful copies made, sent the copies back to Athens, kept the originals and simply let the Athenians keep the silver.
The Greatest Minds of the Age
Nobody knows exactly how many scrolls the Library held. Ancient writers give numbers ranging from 40,000 to 700,000. The true number was probably somewhere in the hundreds of thousands, though many works existed in several copies. Either way, it was by far the largest collection of knowledge in the ancient world.
And it was used. The poet Callimachus created the Pinakes, a gigantic catalogue of Greek literature organized by subject and author, one of the first library catalogues ever made. Eratosthenes, who served as head librarian, worked out the circumference of the Earth with impressive accuracy using nothing more than shadows, measurements and geometry. Scholars at Alexandria edited the poems of Homer into the versions we still read, studied anatomy, mapped the stars and translated the Hebrew scriptures into Greek.
The Famous Fire
The most famous story about the Library’s destruction involves Julius Caesar. In 48 BCE, during a Roman civil war, Caesar was trapped in Alexandria. To stop the Egyptian fleet from cutting him off, he set fire to ships in the harbor. The fire spread to the docks and the buildings near them. Ancient writers say that around 40,000 scrolls were burned.
It was a real loss. But it was probably not the end of the Library. Many historians think the scrolls that burned were stored in warehouses near the harbor, perhaps waiting to be shipped, not in the Library itself. Scholars continued working in Alexandria for centuries afterward.
The Slow Fade
The truth is sadder and less dramatic. The Library did not die in a single night. It faded away over hundreds of years.
In 145 BCE, a later king, Ptolemy VIII, drove many of the scholars out of Alexandria during a political struggle, and they scattered to other cities. Under Roman rule, funding became less reliable, and the Library’s prestige slowly drained away. In the 270s CE, during fighting under the Roman emperor Aurelian, the palace quarter of Alexandria, where the Library and the Mouseion had stood, was badly damaged.
A smaller “daughter library” survived for a while in the Serapeum, a great temple elsewhere in the city. In 391 CE, during conflicts between Christians and followers of the old religions, the Serapeum was destroyed.
There is one more famous story: that in 642 CE, after Arab armies conquered Egypt, the caliph Umar ordered the remaining books to be burned to heat the city’s bathhouses. But that story first appears in writing more than five hundred years after it supposedly happened, and most historians today consider it a legend.
What Was Really Lost
So no single villain destroyed the Library of Alexandria. It was lost to political turmoil, war damage, shrinking budgets and, above all, neglect. Papyrus scrolls are fragile. In a damp climate they rot, and they have to be copied again and again to survive. When nobody pays scribes to copy them, and nobody cares enough to protect them, knowledge slowly disappears.
That may be the most important lesson of the Library. We imagine knowledge being lost to dramatic fires and invasions. More often, it is lost when people simply stop looking after it.
Much of what was in the Library is gone forever: lost plays, poems, histories and scientific works we know only by their titles. But not everything vanished. Copies had spread to other libraries, and some survived through the Middle Ages, preserved by scholars in Constantinople, Baghdad and European monasteries.
In 2002, a new library opened in Alexandria, near where the old one had stood: the Bibliotheca Alexandrina, a vast, tilted disc of glass and granite carved with letters from alphabets all around the world. It was built in memory of the Great Library, and in the hope that this time, the knowledge would be looked after.