THE SHIP THAT NEVER RETURNED

In 1909 a brand-new liner left Durban with 211 people aboard. Not a single plank of her has ever been found.

The Ship That Never Returned

On the evening of 26 July 1909, the steamship Waratah pulled away from the harbor at Durban, South Africa, and turned south along the coast toward Cape Town. She was barely a year old, one of the largest and most luxurious ships on the route between Britain and Australia, and she was carrying 211 people: 92 passengers and 119 crew. She was due in Cape Town in three days.

She never arrived. In more than a century since, not a lifebelt, not a deckchair, not a single body or plank has ever been found that can be proven to have come from her.

The Pride of the Blue Anchor Line

The Waratah was the new flagship of the Blue Anchor Line, built in Glasgow and named after the bright red flower that is the emblem of New South Wales. She had elegant cabins, a music room with a fine organ and space for hundreds of emigrants heading to a new life in Australia. On her maiden voyage in 1908, she had sailed from London to Sydney and back without serious trouble. In 1909, she was on the homeward leg of her second voyage, from Australia back to Britain by way of South Africa.

The Passenger Who Got Off

One passenger did not reboard at Durban. Claude Sawyer, an experienced traveler who had made many sea voyages, had grown uneasy during the trip from Australia. He thought the ship rolled strangely: she would lean far over and then hang there, slow to come back upright, as though she were top-heavy. Then he began having the same dream, night after night, of a man in strange armor holding a bloodstained sword, rising out of the sea and calling his name.

When the ship reached Durban, Sawyer went ashore and sent a telegram to his wife in London: “Thought Waratah top-heavy. Landed Durban.” He booked a passage on a different ship. It was a decision that would make him famous and that he would have to explain, over and over, for the rest of his life.

The Last Sighting

Early on the morning of 27 July, the Waratah overtook a smaller cargo ship, the Clan MacIntyre, off the coast. The two ships exchanged signals by lamp. The Waratah reported that all was well, then steamed ahead and slowly disappeared over the horizon. That is the last time anyone is certain they saw her.

Later that day, the weather changed. A powerful storm swept up the coast, with gale-force winds and huge waves. This stretch of sea, off South Africa’s eastern coast, is notorious among sailors. The strong Agulhas Current runs against the wind there and can raise sudden, monstrous waves, steep walls of water that have damaged even modern ships.

That evening, the crew of another ship, the Harlow, reported seeing the lights of a large steamer behind them, then two bright flashes and darkness. At the time, they thought it was a brush fire on shore. Later, people wondered.

The Waratah had no radio. Wireless was still new in 1909, and she had not been fitted with it. Whatever happened to her, she could not call for help.

The Search

When the ship failed to reach Cape Town, people at first assumed she had broken down and was drifting somewhere. The British navy sent warships to look for her. Then the Blue Anchor Line chartered a steamer, the Sabine, which searched for nearly three months and covered more than 14,000 miles of ocean. Relatives of the passengers raised money for another search ship, the Wakefield, which spent months more combing the southern ocean, even visiting remote islands in case survivors had washed ashore. They found nothing.

In 1910 and 1911, a Board of Trade inquiry was held in London. Claude Sawyer gave evidence about the strange rolling. Others swore the ship was perfectly stable. The inquiry could not reach a definite conclusion, but thought it most likely that the Waratah had capsized in the storm, rolled over so suddenly that no lifeboat could be launched.

The Hunt That Never Ended

The mystery never went away. A South African researcher named Emlyn Brown spent more than twenty years searching the seabed off the coast. In 1999, he announced that sonar had found a wreck in the right area, the right size and shape. Newspapers around the world reported that the Waratah had finally been found. But when divers reached it, the wreck turned out to be the Nailsea Meadow, a cargo ship sunk by a German submarine in 1943. Later searches found other wrecks too. None was her.

Swallowed by the Sea

The Waratah is sometimes called “Australia’s Titanic,” though she vanished three years before the Titanic sank. The Titanic left behind survivors, lifeboats and a wreck on the seabed that people could finally visit. The Waratah left behind only questions.

Was she top-heavy, as Claude Sawyer feared? Did one giant wave roll her over in seconds? Did she break apart, or simply slip beneath the surface in the dark? Somewhere off the coast of South Africa, a great ship and 211 people lie in the deep water. Perhaps one day a diver’s lamp will fall on her name. Until then, she remains one of the great unsolved mysteries of the sea.

Watch the Story

Watch The Ship That Never Returned